Author: PEAK Business Consultancy Services | Published: 2025
Table of Contents
- Introduction
- What is Smart Growth?
- Why Smart Growth Matters in Barrie
- Debunking Density Misconceptions
- Key Principles of Smart Growth in Urban Planning
- Smart Growth and Housing Diversity
- Transit-Oriented Development (TOD) in Barrie
- Public Realm and Green Infrastructure
- Environmental Benefits of Compact Communities
- Economic Efficiency and Land Use Optimization
- Urban Design for Density and Livability
- Zoning Reform and Planning Policy
- Community Engagement and Inclusive Growth
- Case Studies: Barrie’s Smart Growth in Action
- Challenges and Mitigation Strategies
- The Future of Smart Growth in Barrie
- Conclusion
Introduction
As Barrie experiences unprecedented growth, the city stands at a pivotal crossroads: how can it welcome new residents while preserving quality of life, access to green space, and a sense of community? The answer lies in smart growth — an urban planning approach that emphasizes compact, transit-connected, and mixed-use development to create resilient, livable neighborhoods. This blog explores the theory, implementation, and implications of smart growth in Barrie, with a particular focus on how increasing density can enhance — not hinder — livability when done right.
What is Smart Growth?
Smart growth refers to a set of principles and practices that aim to foster sustainable urban development. Rather than prioritizing car-dependent suburban sprawl, smart growth emphasizes walkable neighborhoods, mixed land uses, varied housing options, and efficient infrastructure. The goal is to create vibrant, inclusive communities that are economically viable, environmentally responsible, and socially equitable.
- Compact Building Design
- Walkable Communities
- Transportation Choices
- Strong Sense of Place
- Preservation of Open Space
- Community and Stakeholder Collaboration
Why Smart Growth Matters in Barrie
Barrie is projected to grow to nearly 300,000 people by 2051. With its proximity to the Greater Toronto Area, it has become a key player in regional housing supply. But without careful planning, this growth risks triggering urban sprawl, environmental degradation, and traffic congestion. Smart growth is not just a policy preference — it’s a necessity.
- Efficient use of limited urban land within the city’s defined boundary
- Prevention of car-dependency in newer neighborhoods
- Alignment with provincial mandates from the Growth Plan for the Greater Golden Horseshoe
- Support for Barrie’s climate goals and official plan directives
Debunking Density Misconceptions
Density is often misunderstood as overcrowding, congestion, or loss of privacy. In reality, well-designed density offers:
- More amenities close to home
- Greater housing choice and affordability
- Improved public transport viability
- Enhanced community life through public space vibrancy
Smart growth helps overcome the negative stereotypes of density by ensuring urban form and function are optimized.
Key Principles of Smart Growth in Urban Planning
- Mix Land Uses: Combine residential, commercial, cultural, and institutional uses in one area.
- Create Walkable Neighborhoods: Design streets and paths to prioritize pedestrians and cyclists.
- Preserve Open Space: Integrate parks, trails, and greenways.
- Strengthen Existing Communities: Focus on infill and adaptive reuse instead of sprawl.
- Provide a Variety of Housing Choices: Encourage townhouses, duplexes, co-housing, and apartments.
- Foster Distinctive Communities: Support art, heritage, and community identity.
- Make Development Predictable and Fair: Clear rules and stakeholder collaboration.
- Direct Development Toward Existing Communities: Utilize existing infrastructure.
- Support a Variety of Transportation Options: BRT, microtransit, cycling, and walking.
- Encourage Community Collaboration: Ensure meaningful participation in the planning process.
Smart Growth and Housing Diversity
To ensure density serves everyone, a range of housing types is essential:
- Purpose-built rental housing
- Affordable units in market-based developments (inclusionary zoning)
- Secondary suites and garden homes
- Housing for seniors and accessible units
- Non-profit and co-operative housing
Smart growth encourages “gentle density” to allow neighborhoods to evolve naturally without abrupt change or character loss.
Transit-Oriented Development (TOD) in Barrie
TOD is a land-use strategy that concentrates high-density development around major transit hubs. In Barrie, TOD is centered around:
- Allandale Waterfront GO Station
- Barrie South GO Station
- Future BRT corridors along Essa, Mapleview, and Bayfield
Benefits of TOD include:
- Reduced car ownership
- Increased transit ridership
- Walkable, vibrant districts with active retail frontage
Public Realm and Green Infrastructure
Smart growth mandates that as density increases, so must the quality of public space. Key strategies include:
- Linear parks and trail systems connecting neighborhoods
- Green roofs and rooftop gardens in multi-unit buildings
- Public plazas, courtyards, and laneways designed for programming and gatherings
- Street trees, bioswales, and rain gardens to manage stormwater
Environmental Benefits of Compact Communities
Compact urban form reduces emissions by:
- Lowering vehicle kilometers traveled per capita
- Minimizing energy use for heating/cooling
- Supporting active and public transport
- Preserving greenfield lands and habitat corridors
Barrie’s Official Plan commits to net-zero by 2050, and smart growth is a cornerstone in achieving this.
Economic Efficiency and Land Use Optimization
- Smart growth reduces per capita infrastructure costs (sewers, roads, utilities)
- Compact development increases property tax revenue per hectare
- Supports a 24-hour economy with mixed-use zones
- Encourages local job creation and live-work opportunities
Urban Design for Density and Livability
Great urban design ensures that higher density enhances quality of life:
- Mid-rise buildings with stepbacks for human scale
- Active ground-floor uses with transparent façades
- Noise mitigation, daylight access, and ventilation in towers
- Façade variety, materials, and landscaping for visual interest
Zoning Reform and Planning Policy
Barrie is undertaking zoning updates that include:
- Allowing triplexes, fourplexes, and townhomes in all residential areas
- Eliminating minimum parking requirements in transit zones
- Form-based codes to prioritize design and form over land use exclusivity
- Incentives for green building and affordable housing units
Community Engagement and Inclusive Growth
Smart growth is most effective when shaped by the people who live there. Barrie’s approach includes:
- Participatory budgeting for public realm upgrades
- Neighbourhood design workshops and pop-up consultations
- Equity impact assessments on planning decisions
- Youth and newcomer representation in advisory committees
Case Studies: Barrie’s Smart Growth in Action
Debut Condos
This downtown waterfront project combines residential towers with retail, hospitality, and public space in one of the city’s most strategic growth areas.
Park Place District
Formerly a retail center, this area is evolving into a vertical mixed-use neighborhood with transit-oriented density, bike lanes, and community spaces.
Dunlop Street Revitalization
Streetscape improvements, heritage façades, and live-work housing show how small-scale infill can catalyze walkable urbanism in historic areas.
Challenges and Mitigation Strategies
- NIMBYism: Address through education, design excellence, and pilot programs
- Affordability: Preserve low-income units through policy and incentives
- Traffic Impacts: Invest in transit and cycling before approving dense projects
- Construction Disruption: Require mitigation plans and community notification
The Future of Smart Growth in Barrie
By 2051, Barrie could become a national leader in sustainable urbanism if it continues to implement smart growth principles. Key goals include:
- Mixed-use districts linked by zero-emission public transport
- Diverse, inclusive neighborhoods with affordable housing choices
- Net-zero buildings and infrastructure
- Vibrant public spaces that foster civic engagement and culture
Conclusion
Smart growth is not a buzzword — it’s a blueprint for building a better Barrie. By managing density with care, foresight, and community input, Barrie can grow sustainably while preserving what makes it great. As the city densifies, livability doesn’t have to suffer — it can flourish.
Explore More:
