Author: PEAK Business Consultancy Services | Published: 2025
Table of Contents
- Introduction
- What Are Mixed-Use Developments?
- Why Barrie? Urbanization Trends and Local Context
- Policy and Planning Framework Supporting Mixed-Use Development
- Notable Mixed-Use Projects in Downtown Barrie
- Economic Impact and Commercial Viability
- Housing Supply, Density, and Affordability
- Transportation Integration and Transit-Oriented Growth
- Walkability, Placemaking, and Public Realm Enhancement
- Climate Action and Sustainable Urbanism
- Urban Design, Architecture, and Heritage Integration
- Challenges and Controversies
- Future Vision: What Downtown Barrie Could Look Like by 2040
- Conclusion
Introduction
As Barrie transitions from a suburban commuter town to a mid-sized urban hub, its downtown core is experiencing a renaissance led by a surge in mixed-use developments. These transformative projects aim to blend residential, commercial, and civic functions into unified architectural footprints, changing how people live, work, shop, and interact in Barrie’s central neighborhoods.
This blog offers an in-depth exploration of the rise of mixed-use developments in Barrie’s core, examining the factors driving this shift, the planning principles behind it, the projects currently reshaping the skyline, and the broader impacts on economy, sustainability, transportation, and quality of life. With projections through 2040 and insights into city policies, architectural trends, and resident feedback, this analysis provides a comprehensive view of the most significant urban evolution Barrie has undertaken in decades.
What Are Mixed-Use Developments?
Mixed-use development is a type of urban development that combines residential, commercial, cultural, and institutional functions into one cohesive project, often within a single building or contiguous block. These developments promote land use efficiency, reduce the need for vehicle travel, and enhance the vibrancy of urban life. They typically include:
- Residential units (condos, apartments, rentals)
- Retail storefronts or cafes at street level
- Offices, coworking spaces, or health clinics on upper levels
- Integrated public spaces such as plazas, parks, or community centers
- Proximity to transit stations, bike paths, or pedestrian-friendly corridors
Why Barrie? Urbanization Trends and Local Context
Barrie has grown steadily in population, reaching over 160,000 residents as of 2025. With expectations to surpass 250,000 by 2051, demand for sustainable, high-density development has intensified. Several local trends contribute to the city’s shift toward mixed-use projects:
- Geographic Constraints: The lake to the north and urban boundary limits to the south create pressure to build up, not out.
- GO Transit Expansion: Enhanced commuter connectivity to Toronto increases the need for walkable downtown housing near stations.
- Downtown Renewal Strategy: Policies since 2015 have aimed to revitalize Barrie’s waterfront, Dunlop Street, and the Allandale district through density and vibrancy.
- Changing Demographics: Young professionals, retirees, and immigrants seek modern housing, short commutes, and lifestyle amenities in one place.
Policy and Planning Framework Supporting Mixed-Use Development
Barrie’s Official Plan (2023) lays out specific zoning reforms and urban growth boundaries to support mixed-use intensification. Key policies include:
- Urban Growth Centre Designation: Encourages high-rise residential and commercial development in the downtown core.
- Major Transit Station Areas (MTSAs): Identified for high-density, mixed-use developments within 500–800m of GO Stations.
- Inclusionary Zoning: Requires a percentage of new developments to include affordable housing near transit corridors.
- Flexible Zoning: Allows retail and office uses in traditionally residential areas and vice versa.
- Design Guidelines: New developments must adhere to urban design principles that promote pedestrian access, building articulation, and public realm improvements.
Notable Mixed-Use Projects in Downtown Barrie
1. Debut Condos & Hotel (Meridian Place)
A two-tower project near the lakefront featuring residential units, retail space, and a boutique hotel. The project anchors Barrie’s waterfront revitalization and introduces public plaza space for festivals and community gatherings.
2. SmartCentres Barrie Downtown (Former Barrie Central School Site)
Slated to include more than 800 residential units, a major grocery store, medical offices, and new retail, this redevelopment is central to creating a walkable community around Allandale GO.
3. Dunlop Street Corridor
Numerous mid-rise and high-rise mixed-use buildings are proposed or under construction, blending modern architecture with preserved heritage façades. These offer live-work units, retail at grade, and rooftop green spaces.
4. Park Place Mixed-Use District
Although technically in south Barrie, Park Place is evolving into a major mixed-use node combining residential towers with office space, retail, restaurants, and recreational infrastructure.
Economic Impact and Commercial Viability
Mixed-use developments significantly impact local economies:
- Increased Property Value: Land near mixed-use hubs tends to appreciate faster due to location desirability.
- Business Incubation: Retail and office spaces embedded in residential towers support small businesses and startups.
- Local Employment: On-site offices and storefronts create jobs close to home, reducing commuting burdens.
- Tax Revenue Growth: Intensification increases the property tax base without expanding service areas.
Housing Supply, Density, and Affordability
High-rise mixed-use projects add hundreds of new units in a single development, helping to alleviate housing shortages. Advantages include:
- Vertical living enables more units on smaller land parcels
- Inclusionary zoning ensures a mix of income levels
- Efficient utility distribution and shared building amenities
- Supports demographic diversity from students to seniors
However, affordability remains a concern. Market forces continue to push prices upward, necessitating ongoing public-private collaboration for affordable housing integration.
Transportation Integration and Transit-Oriented Growth
Mixed-use projects thrive on access to mobility. Key transportation links near new developments include:
- Allandale Waterfront and Barrie South GO Stations
- Barrie Transit Terminal and proposed Bus Rapid Transit corridors
- Expanded cycling infrastructure connecting neighborhoods to employment and retail hubs
- Micro-mobility support (bike lockers, e-scooter docks)
Proximity to transit reduces car dependency, supports environmental goals, and fosters healthier, more active lifestyles.
Walkability, Placemaking, and Public Realm Enhancement
Modern mixed-use developments emphasize walkability and quality public space. Features include:
- Wide sidewalks, patios, and landscaping encouraging street life
- Urban squares, fountains, and art installations open to the public
- Connections to waterfront trails and linear parks
- Retail clustering that supports spontaneous commerce and community interaction
Climate Action and Sustainable Urbanism
Sustainable design elements embedded in mixed-use developments include:
- Green roofs and rooftop solar panels
- Stormwater management systems (bioswales, permeable pavements)
- Building energy efficiency certifications (LEED, BOMA BEST)
- Waste diversion programs within residential towers
- Shared heating/cooling systems reducing emissions
Urban Design, Architecture, and Heritage Integration
Downtown Barrie’s architectural character is protected through careful urban design guidelines. Mixed-use projects must:
- Respect existing heritage façades through façade retention or adaptive reuse
- Use step-backs and podium massing to preserve human scale
- Incorporate public art or community storytelling in building design
- Prioritize high-quality materials and timeless aesthetics
Challenges and Controversies
Despite its promise, mixed-use development is not without issues:
- Gentrification: Rising property values may displace long-time residents and businesses
- Parking Debates: Reduced parking minimums create tension with car-dependent users
- Construction Disruption: Downtown projects bring dust, noise, and traffic detours
- Design Pushback: Concerns over “glass tower” aesthetics clashing with historic fabric
Public consultation and participatory planning are crucial to balancing growth with community interests.
Future Vision: What Downtown Barrie Could Look Like by 2040
By 2040, Barrie’s downtown could feature:
- 30+ mixed-use towers between 8–25 storeys
- Hundreds of new retail and food service businesses
- Thousands of new residents living within walking distance of transit
- New cultural institutions, event venues, and learning hubs embedded into projects
- Self-contained 15-minute neighborhoods promoting social, environmental, and economic health
Conclusion
The rise of mixed-use developments in Barrie’s core marks a watershed moment in the city’s evolution. It’s not just about taller buildings or denser neighborhoods — it’s about reimagining what kind of city Barrie can become: vibrant, sustainable, equitable, and connected. Through bold design, sound policy, and thoughtful implementation, Barrie is poised to become a model for mid-sized cities embracing 21st-century urbanism.
Learn More:
